Fans of sci fi noticed a exchange when Andy Weir, the author of Project Hail Mary, appeared on the Critical Drinker podcast. While talking about his attempt to pitch a new Star Trek series, he said the showrunners were “nice guys” but also called the shows “s**t” and added a blunt remark about the rejection. The clip spread quickly online and sparked a backlash.
Weir’s Public Apology
On Facebook, Weir posted a candid open letter addressed to Alex Kurtzman, the executive producer who leads the current Star Trek era. He wrote that he was trying to be funny but that his words sounded disrespectful and mean. He explained that the short clips did not capture his full intent and that he was being self deprecating.
Weir emphasized his respect for Kurtzman as a person. He said, “He is a really nice guy and I still like you as a person.” He also offered to discuss the matter in real time, inviting Kurtzman to call or Zoom him even if the conversation turned harsh.
Reactions from the Community
Other authors joined the conversation. Don Winslow, known for Crime 101, pushed back against Weir’s original remarks, adding fuel to the online debate. Many readers praised Weir for owning his mistake, while some remained critical of his initial tone.
Impact on Weir’s Career
At the same time, Weir enjoys strong momentum from the success of Project Hail Mary. The novel’s film adaptation, directed by Phil Lord and Christopher Miller and starring Ryan Gosling, is performing well for Amazon MGM Studios. This success shows that original sci fi stories can still draw large audiences.
What This Means for Future Projects
The apology may open a door for future dialogue between Weir and the Star Trek team. By acknowledging his misstep, Weir shows he values professional relationships. Whether Kurtzman accepts the offer to talk remains unknown, but the drama has shifted from heated comments to a sincere attempt at repair.
Overall, the incident reminds creators that words spread fast online and that a quick, honest apology can help calm a storm. Fans now watch for any sign of collaboration between the author of Project Hail Mary and the Star Trek franchise.
Source: Geek Tyrant
