Review: The Mountain Between Us Pulls A Fast One Us

The Mountain Between Us [Credit: 20th Century Fox]

The Mountain Between Us may leave some audiences confused depending on their expectations for the film. It was curious, though how the trailers portrayed the movie to be one way, and the film ended up being completely different. Full disclosure: this film is based on the novel (of the same name) by Charles Martin,  in which I have not read prior to viewing.

The Good:

Let us begin with the fact the film doesn’t spend a long time with getting into the suspense that was advertised. Probably one of the most visual standouts of the movie will be the plane crash. (As seen in the trailer) What I appreciated was how the camera within the plane captured the entire scene as if you (the audience) were one of the passengers as well. Describing the scene is one thing, but seeing it is another.

The Mountain Between Us [Credit: 20th Century Fox]
The Mountain Between Us [Credit: 20th Century Fox]

As the story progresses, we get a handful of suspenseful moments. Personally, some of those moments had me at the edge of my seat. A lot of the dangers that are faced by the characters were very realistic and practical. I thought it was interesting to have the characters know as much as they did in terms of survival techniques. It’s a little crazy because while many of the things that Idris’s character did made sense (being a doctor and all), Kate Winslet’s character felt like a human Google Search.

I think the biggest strength in The Mountain Between Us is without question the acting performances. Kate Winslet shines in her role given the tough decisions and realizations that she makes throughout the film. However, I’d have to say that Idris Elba wins out a bit more. I think that’s because Idris simply had more to work with within his role.

The Bad:

Unfortunately, as much as the marketing for this film tries to promote  itself as an intense survival thriller, it’s simply not the case. The film is more of a romance than anything. There’s nothing wrong a romantic genre of course. However,  if you’re selling people on the survival aspects, and not so much the drama, then disappointment will surely enter into the equation. Not to mention the fact that you have probably missed out on catering the film to the audiences that actually would care to see a romantic drama.

As a result of this genre fake-out, it should be noted that while the suspenseful moments previously mentioned are good, they are few and far in between. It takes a while for something exciting to happen in the film, because for the majority of the time we’re listening to a lot of dialogue. Dialogue that I personally thought gets a bit monotonous after a point in the film. Especially when some of the dialogue keeps trying to poke at a very obvious issue with one of the characters. (Yeah, I side-eyed Kate Winslet a number of times.)

The Mountain Between Us [Credit: 20th Century Fox]
The Mountain Between Us [Credit: 20th Century Fox]
Due to the slow pacing of the film, it really makes you feel as though it’s much longer than it actually may be. The plot is just not as engaging as it may be compared to the novel. Dare I say, it’s only when danger presents itself that your interest may be rekindled to keep on watching.

Worst of all, the writing for this story did the film no justice at all. The relationship, interactions, and feelings between the Winslet and Elba’s characters never feels authentic. As a matter of fact, it almost feels forced. While the actors performed as best they could, the plot was overly predictable in many situations. It also didn’t help that the director felt the need to include such a cheesy and cliche’ romantic ending shot in the film. (You’ll know it when you see it, and don’t be surprised if it arouses an eye-roll.)

The Verdict:

The Mountain Between Us is the type of movie that hoped it could be carried more so by its star power rather than the story itself. Sadly, I don’t think any of the biggest Hollywood stars could help this film. You should know going into the film that it is probably 65% romance/drama and only 35% suspenseful survival story. If you go in with those expectations, I think you’ll better appreciate the film. I couldn’t recommend this for more than a matinee or maybe a rental viewing at best.

Genre: Drama| Adventure | Romance
Directed by: Hany Abu-Assad
Starring: Idris Elba, Kate Winslet, Beau Bridges 
Written by: J. Mills Goodloe, Charles Martin 

See The Mountain Between Us in theaters now!  Be sure to follow Eman’s Movie Reviews on Facebook, Subscribe on YouTube, or follow me on Twitter/IG @EmansReviews for even more movie news and reviews!

Past Reviews/Articles You May Like:

About Emmanuel "E-Man" Noisette

Emmanuel is a Chicago film critic who founded Eman's Movie Reviews. He freelances as a writer and video content creator for sites such as MovieTickets.com. Be sure to join the other 33K+ fans on his Facebook Fan Page for even more movie opinions and fun. Feel free to contact him with any professional inquiries: [email protected]