Former United States Champion Bishop Dyer spoke out after Carmelo Hayes lost his US title on the March 27 episode of SmackDown. Dyer told fans that Hayes earned a spot at WrestleMania 42 and that the decision to hand the belt to Sami Zayn felt unfair. He posted on Twitter, urging WWE to add Hayes to the upcoming match between Zayn and Trick Williams.
Viewers flooded social media with criticism. On YouTube, the match highlights drew thousands of comments that called the finish a mistake. On X, Triple H shared a promo that promoted the Zayn versus Williams bout, but fans replied that Hayes deserved the championship at the Grandest Stage of Them All.
Many users quoted Dyer’s request for a three way match. One tweet read, “Make it a three way!! @Carmelo_WWE has carried that for months and has delivered!!” Another post said, “Just my opinion but @Carmelo_WWE got screwed. He deserves a Mania match!!” The consensus shows a strong desire to see Hayes back in the title picture.
How WWE Could Fix the Situation Before WrestleMania 42
WWE has several options to calm the upset. First, they could insert Hayes into the Zayn versus Williams match as a third competitor. Adding Hayes would create a dynamic three way that satisfies fans and highlights the US Championship.
Second, WWE could book a rematch on SmackDown. Hayes could confront General Manager Nick Aldis, demand a fair shot, and earn a title opportunity later in the week. This storyline would give Hayes a clear path while keeping the narrative fresh.
Potential Third Participants
Ilja Dragunov has been involved in the US title scene for months. Including Dragunov would add a hard‑hitting style that fans love. Another name is Tama Tonga, who was mentioned by Hayes during the open challenge. Tonga could step up and challenge Zayn, creating a fresh rivalry.
Any of these scenarios would restore interest in the US Championship and give Hayes the spotlight he earned during his 98‑day reign. Hayes defended the belt nine times on television, showing consistency and charisma that fans appreciate.
Long Term Benefits
By addressing the controversy, WWE can show that it listens to its audience. A well‑planned match at WrestleMania 42 could boost viewership and social engagement. It also reinforces the importance of the US title as a stepping stone for rising stars.
Overall, the best path forward is to give Carmelo Hayes a fair chance to compete for the US Championship at WrestleMania. Whether through a three way match or a direct rematch, WWE has the tools to turn the current backlash into a memorable moment.
Source: Wrestletalk
