I don’t think you read half of what I wrote.
My complaint was NOT that all the monsters, characters and locations were not faithfully recreated, because for the most part they were – it certainly looked the part.
If you’d have read the comment, or complaint as you put it (and this is an open movie opinion board, I CAN complain if I want to) properly, you’d have seen that my main criticism is that the one thing that is most important to Silent Hill is how it brings out the protagonist’s darkest fears, secrets, etc and projects them into Silent Hill itself; this was lost in translation (or plain ignored), hence the reason why the monsters were just visually impressive obstacles rather disturbing mental images.

And I’m sure there is a new team on the next film and I’m more than happy to be blown away by it but if it’s all the same with you, I’ll remain sceptical. I was simply having a reflective opinion; don’t tell me I can’t have it and that I’m being rude, just because my opinion bums you out.

Thank you

PLEASE STOP COMPLAINING ABOUT HOW THE FIRST MOVIE WASN’T LIKE THE GAMES.

if everything HAD to be like the games, the resident evil movies wouldn’t have gotten me so annoyed. I did my research. they went on four, yes, FOUR, fan sites, MAJOR ones, and had the FANS vote on the monsters that would be in.

Pyramid head and those certain nurses won.

They went to the Japanese game directors before releasing the movie.

THEY LIKED IT.

they liked that the main character was a mom and not Harry, because too many american movies revolve around men.

they liked the whole thing. if they did, then there’s no real reason to be upset.

Also, one more thing I found by research.

the plots for Silenthill, and characters, since game out, were AMERICAN MADE.

it was sold to Japan. and then Japan said, “AMERICA!! MAKE YOUR OWN GAMES!!”

And sold it back.

Also, if anyone else bothered to do research, the people directing the new movie had NO part in the first, and the first directors have NO part in this one.

They have amazing casting, I’ve seen some B. A screenshots and monsters.

Get out of the mindset that the movie HAS to be an exact REPLICA of the games. NOT GONNA HAPPEN.

I’m NOT being rude, I’m just pointing out what SHOULD be the obvious.

So please, please PLEASE stop complaining. You’re ruining it for those of us who are actually exciting, and THAT’S rude.

WOOOO FOR SILENT HILL 3D REVOLUTION!!

or…whatever it’s called.