Once again, you’re not even listening to me. Yeah, if Steven Spielberg were doing it, it would be a 100% different story, because in the last 20 years, he’s done 10 films, all of which were better than Shitty Feet or Babe 2, including several projects that demonstrate he’d be a much better fit than Miller.

And Nolan? Memento, The Prestige, Insomnia, Batman Begins (all FAR superior to anything Miller has done in the last 20 years)… all done in the last few years who knows and understands the demographic that JL would be targeting a lot better than Miller would.

If all you want to do is keep referring to a movie that miller did in 1979, then why don’t we just suggest that George Lucas direct JL cause no movie Miller did even comes close to how good Star Wars is.

I really enjoyed Babe 2, but you’ll never find it on any credible “all time” lists. Happy Feet was total political propogandized garbage that didn’t deserve a lick of the attention it got.

There are TONS of directors who would be a better fit for JL. That’s not to say that all of them are better directors than George Miller is in general or all time… but a better fit for this particular project.

What about Chris Nolan? I like his movies, but he hasn’t made a movie half as good as Mad Max, Road Warrior or Babe 2. We could still tell that he would bring something interesting to Batman Begins, and he did (although Miller could teach him a lot about directing action). Miller has a longer, better track record and I would argue that the movies he’s already made are more applicable to what he’s going to be doing with Justice League.

And I still don’t know what his age has to do with it. Spielberg is 60 I think. If he was doing it would you have said he was too old? What if Scorsese wanted to do it for some reason? You’d be mad because he’s too old?

Anyway, you’re not going to say any directors you think would be “a good fit”? I thought you’d have some ideas.

And you still don’t get the point do you? I never said Miller isn’t a good director… but a 62 year old guy who has only directed 2 kids movies in the last 20 years is not a good fit for JL. Hell, take away the mad max franchise (even though Thunderdome was a sack of shit) and he doesn’t have all that much on his resume)

“the guy who made dancing penguins seem as epic as Lord of the Rings”

Ummm… wow… did you really just say that? Hey, to each their own I guess, you’re entitled to your opinion, and your opinion is every bit as valid as mine… but we are clearly operating on two different levels of reality here.

I’m a Batman nerd, I like the Justice League cartoon, and I like some of these other characters. But I never really thought a Justice League movie could work until I heard the name George Miller. I want to see the director of Road Warrior do a chase scene with the Flash. I want to see how the creator of Mad Max handles the character of Batman. I want to see what the genius behind the megalopolis in Babe: Pig in the City and Barter Town in Beyond Thunderdome does visually to create a world of super heroes. I want to see what the guy who made dancing penguins seem as epic as Lord of the Rings will do with DC Comics.

He is the perfect director. As long as they let him do what he wants he will make a great movie.

You say he’s the wrong director. So who’s the right director?